The best way to evaluate employee performance accurately and fairly: a complete guide

Employees are the foundation of every company, and its progress and goals depend on them. That is why it matters to evaluate each employee's performance and make sure they fit the role and support the company's goals.

In this article you will learn what employee performance appraisal is and why it matters, the core criteria for evaluating effectively, and the best way to evaluate employee performance in your company.

You will also see how technology and artificial intelligence (AI) improve performance appraisal, the steps for running an appraisal in Dawmt, and how Dawmt's reports support the way you evaluate your employees.

What is employee performance appraisal, and why does it matter?

According to the Society for Human Resource Management (SHRM), employee performance appraisal is part of human resources (HR) management: a process for monitoring how employees carry out their tasks, how well they do them, and what their strengths and weaknesses are. The process helps raise performance and gives employees the support they need at work. It is one of the things a company's growth depends on, and the next section explains why.

Why is employee performance appraisal important for companies?

Performance evaluation has a real effect on a company's productivity and growth. Here is why it matters:

• Higher productivity

Evaluating employees shows what is missing from each person's work and what they need to improve. Working on those gaps raises the employee's performance, and with it their productivity.

• Spotting performance problems

Monitoring and evaluating performance closely reveals the problems that hold improvement back, and shows whether improvement is possible or something is standing in the way. Once a problem is identified, it can be solved quickly.

• Professional development

An appraisal gives the employee guidance and advice that support their professional development and career growth. A stronger employee makes a bigger contribution, and the company grows with them.

• Identifying strengths and weaknesses

An appraisal shows the company each employee's strengths and weaknesses, so it can make the most of the strengths and work on the weaknesses to improve productivity.

• Motivation

An accurate appraisal tells the company how to motivate each employee and what makes them more engaged and productive, whether that is incentives, bonuses or another approach. It points the company to the best way to bring out each employee's best performance.

• Checking that the company's goals are being met

An appraisal shows whether each employee is working towards the company's goals. The company can then make the right decisions to reach those goals and guide its employees towards them.

Read more: The best HR software for managing employees and running your company efficiently

Core criteria for an effective performance appraisal

To evaluate performance effectively and get useful results, you need to know the core criteria. These are the criteria for evaluating employee performance:

• Quality of work: monitor and assess the quality of each employee's work, because it is one of the most important criteria the process rests on.
• Productivity: how productive the employee is, and whether they do what is asked of them quickly and well.
• Achieving goals: the employee's ability to reach the goals set for them, or the goals their tasks are meant to achieve.
• Initiative: whether the employee knows how to take the lead and finish work without needing much help.
• Teamwork: the employee's ability to work in a team, deal with colleagues, and use that collaboration to reach the company's goals.
• Communication: one of the most important criteria is how well the employee communicates with others in the company, both colleagues in the same field and people in other departments.
• Commitment: the area to focus on most is how committed the employee is to deadlines, to completing tasks, and to working hours.
• Professional experience: assess the employee's skills, experience and knowledge of their field, and whether that experience actually helps the company reach its goals.
• Flexibility: the employee's ability to adapt to change, pressure, or a heavy workload.
• Problem solving: a core criterion for modern companies is the employee's ability to handle problems and solve them correctly.

Read more: The integrated HR management system: a guide to your company's success

Common problems with traditional appraisal methods

Traditional appraisal methods, which rely on people doing the work by hand, face several problems:

• Personal opinion

The person responsible for appraising employees may not be fully neutral and may not overcome bias or personal opinion, which can make the appraisal inaccurate or unfair.

• Missed deadlines

A manual appraisal takes a lot of time. Companies usually need a monthly or annual report on their employees, and the person responsible for it often cannot finish on time, so time and deadlines are a major problem with traditional methods.

• No view of past performance

An appraisal needs continuous follow-up and a record of the employee's past performance to show how they have grown. Traditional methods may not give you an accurate picture of past performance, so you cannot compare or analyse it.

• Small details are missed

Traditional methods do not reach the small details of an employee's performance, because no one person can notice and record that much detail for every employee.

• A heavier load on employees

Traditional methods can be difficult and time-consuming for the employee running them, which makes the appraisal a burden they may not complete properly.

• Weak link to strategic goals

A major problem with traditional appraisal is how hard it is to link each employee's appraisal to the company's goals and to show its effect on them. Modern methods support those goals at every step, including showing how each employee's appraisal supports them.

HR system

What is the best way to evaluate employee performance in companies in Saudi Arabia?

Companies in Saudi Arabia use many methods to get the best results from their employees. The following steps will help you evaluate employee performance accurately and get solid results:

• Set clear goals: before you evaluate an employee, set clear goals that you want to reach through that employee and that you want them to work towards.
• Continuous follow-up: follow the employee's work continuously rather than only once a year. Evaluate monthly, for example, or weekly if you can, because this follow-up makes the appraisal far more accurate.
• Share your observations: tell the employee from time to time what you have observed in their work, and explain it precisely. This makes the appraisal better and helps you understand the details of the employee's work.
• Use the right method: choose the appraisal method that suits you, for example a rating from 1 to 5, an assessment based on the number and type of tasks the employee completes, or meetings with managers and colleagues. Each person has a method they can apply properly, so choose the one that fits.
• Transparency: be clear with the employee about their strengths and weaknesses, the gaps they need to work on, and the strengths they should keep. This clarity also makes later appraisals easier.
• Use tools and software: use modern software to collect information and give you every report and data point on employee performance. Dawmt, for example, helps you manage your employees in full, and you can use it to evaluate each employee.
• 360-degree feedback: a method that gathers views on the employee from several sources instead of relying on one opinion. We explain the concept and its benefits in detail in Performance appraisal system.

So the best way to evaluate employee performance is not one step or one thing, but a set of core steps.

Sign up for Dawmt

How technology and AI improve employee performance appraisal

Now that you know the best way to evaluate employee performance, it helps to know that technology and AI now play a central role in every field, including employee appraisal. They help in these ways:

• Drafting appraisals and feedback

You can give AI the data and details about an employee and their performance, and it drafts appraisals and feedback that help you evaluate the employee. It also gives you ideas you might not have noticed, which makes the appraisal more accurate.

• Analysis

Using technology in appraisal gives you detailed analysis of the cases and details you enter into the software, which helps you understand performance in more depth.

• Help setting goals

AI can help you set the company's goals and what is expected of each employee, based on details about the company. Clear goals make appraisal easier, because you assess the employee's progress towards each goal.

• Planning the appraisal

AI helps you plan the appraisal, so you can set every criterion, idea and goal you will evaluate against. You can also enter employee data to get a more precise plan.

• Avoiding bias

Evaluating with the help of AI helps you avoid bias and personal opinion, and keeps the appraisal transparent.

• Automating the process

AI can build a complete employee appraisal process by automating its different steps without human intervention.

Read more: AI in HR: transforming how employee data is analysed

Steps for running a performance appraisal in Dawmt

To run an appraisal in Dawmt correctly and accurately, follow these steps:

1. Open the performance management section and choose "Performance management".
2. Create a new appraisal cycle and choose its period: quarterly, half-yearly or annual.
3. Set up the appraisal form and add goals for each employee.
4. Set a weighting for each goal and choose the rating scale.
5. Add the key competencies, such as commitment, collaboration or speed.
6. The manager opens the file to rate the goals and competencies and adds notes that support the rating.
7. HR reviews the appraisals and corrects any score or weighting that is wrong or biased.
8. Issue the reports, and the manager and HR approve the appraisal.

Contact the Dawmt team

How Dawmt's reports help you evaluate employee performance accurately and fairly

Dawmt's reports give you a wealth of information that makes appraisal more accurate. As an HR system, Dawmt provides detailed reports that make the appraisal process more precise. Here is what Dawmt's reports do:

• They give the company accurate analysis and data, which makes the appraisal fairer.
• They keep a regular record of each employee's performance, not one taken at long intervals: it can be daily if that is what the company wants.
• They save a lot of time and effort, so the people responsible for appraisal can focus on the details.
• They support decisions with the information and analysis they provide about each employee and their performance.
• They make the data and details transparent, which makes appraisal both easier and more accurate.

Sign up for Dawmt to get the tools that help you evaluate your employees, along with an integrated HR system that makes managing your company more organised and productive.

Sign up for Dawmt